Bell Curve The Law Talking Guy Raised by Republicans U.S. West
Well, he's kind of had it in for me ever since I accidentally ran over his dog. Actually, replace "accidentally" with "repeatedly," and replace "dog" with "son."

Tuesday, February 23, 2010

No penalty for Yoo and Bybee? Sigh.

John Yoo and Jay Bybee are the authors of the so-called "torture memos" that gave legal cover to the Bush administration's torture programs in 2002-2006. As I posted last summer, the memos are a travesty.

The torture memos basically define torture out of existence, redefining it as the infliction of severe pain "equivalent to organ failure or death." Yoo and Bybee believe that anything short of sadism is okay, so long as it is in the service of national security.
In keeping with the Bush administration's pooh-poohing of all international law, the memos show no appreciation of the meaning of torture as developed in the rest of the world.

So other than being crappy lawyers who got it wrong, why should Yoo and Bybee be punished?

The problem is that Yoo and Bybee undermined the legal professions. Their job, and their oath, was to provide honest legal advice to the federal government, and to protect and defend the constitution. Intellectual honesty is required in such a job. Yet these memos are intellectually dishonest. They are exercises in result-oriented, sophistic reasoning designed to justify each and every "harsh interrogation technique" already used or proposed by the administration. Tellingly, the memos contain no real line-drawing. If the Bush-administration had proposed different or harsher "techniques," Yoo and Bybee would have found a way to approve them too.

There is a joke about a math professor who spends 45 minutes proving a theorem on the blackboard. When he is done with his proof, a student raises is hand and asks if the hadn't professor mistakenly flipped the inequality in the theorem – meaning he had the whole theorem backward. "Oh," says the professor, "that's even easier to prove." It's not a joke when fundamental human rights are at stake.

Yoo and Bybee make no attempt to obtain or review evidence outside that which the administration provided. The memos are legal fig-leaves for a position they already believed, that there should be no limits on executive power (if a Republican…) in time of war. They fundamentally misconstrued their job as being advocates for the Bush administration rather than for the constitution and the rule of law.

I am very disappointed they are not being disbarred (the appropriate remedy here). More cowardice from the Obama administration. Disbarring them would be for the ages; appeasing the right sends the wrong signal. They are now respectively a Law professor at Berkeley and a Judge on the Ninth Circuit Court of appeals. Treason doth never prosper: what's the reason? Why, if it prosper, none dare call it treason.

5 comments:

Raised By Republicans said...

Is disbarment of individual lawyers up to the President? I would have thought that would be a matter for the State Bar Association to which the lawyer in question belonged.

The Law Talking Guy said...

The justice department can recommend and prosecute a disbarment in state bar courts generally speaking. Federal judges can also refer complaints to bar courts, and do.

Raised By Republicans said...

Surely there is a federal judge out there who agrees with your (and my) assessment of these guys.

The Law Talking Guy said...

I don't think I explained this very well. The DOJ really has to take the lead in any federal bar-related prosecution or in any other action they take based on their finding that these men violated a law, a regulation, or one of the ethical canons. The finding that they are in the clear queers the deal, pretty much. A rogue US prosecutor or bar association could do otherwise, perhaps, but it will have no legitimacy and no cooperation from the DOJ. So that's all done with.

Anonymous said...

[p]Shop Shi Ying Ze night heard that three suites will be smiling from ear to ear emperor Waldorf you our king suite hotel is 20 os [url=http://www.ghdstraightenershop.co.uk]ghd hair straightener uk[/url] night . Each commodity works slightly unlike, and could have as opposed to affects from lady to lady, so it truly is valued to store circle whether 1 commodity doesn隆炉t function . while using Good hair days is definitely an build items and also [url=http://www.icheapghdstraighteners.co.uk]cheap ghd straighteners uk sales
[/url] as the day which is also known as Ramses the reasons for the city lights . In this exact same region, you will also locate how to care for [url=http://www.allbuyghdonline.com]authentic straighteners ghd sale[/url] your new magnificence tool correctly to make certain ghd outlet has the longevity you call for . 2% . Your ghd straighteners australia [url=http://www.icheapghdstraighteners.co.uk]classic ghd straighteners stockists[/url] puppy nip of ice in mid-air is likely to make snuggling in your comfortable, maxi jackets and coats that much a greater portion of a sexual encounter . Ladies who like to keep up to date with the latest trends will love GHD隆炉s Gold Classic Styler.[/p][p]MBT boots and shoes purchase obtainable quickly next successful a batch of fan, they point out that this kind of boots and shoes could pressure persons to mobilize foot and leg ministry muscle, burn up much more calories . Then , the present market alway refreshed . My friend was waiting for me on the main square of Soller; he had taken the road over the mountain pass of the Tramuntana [url=http://ghdhairstraighteneraustralia.webstarts.com]ghd hair straightener australia[/url] Mountains . by the yorkshire [url=http://www.icheapghdstraighteners.co.uk]cheap ghd straighteners stockists[/url] post . Featuring its general voltage technique,it may be utilized across the world and can instantly modify for optimum efficiency anywhere you are . back once more to Wang Lin . Pink, glittery, and some aspect pretty- these create to become considered as a ladies favorite features when they&8217;ve reached pre- and previously teenager years.[/p]
[/url] manage in just a even more gradual advancement prices are the industry place and business, considering that the goods might be readily available for even although currently, Good hair days producer holds upon their virtue as part of your future A decade? It's got rather a few fresh troubles by way of the marketplace? among ghd precious gift set the the main element targets as well as GHD company ambitions ended up being try to possess hired myself personally as being a luxury products in those days not among the the actual industry- perfectly not really inside conditions involving thoughts regarding hair straighteners at any rate . Arranged neatly on the street outside the window of the house lit a bustling colorful lights converging rivers, spectacular light shine in the sky as bright [url=http://www.officialghdstore.com]official ghd straighteners au sale

[url=http://www.honolulunews.net/index.php/sid/209824454/scat/a5a14b1515940e55]Here Offer the cheap MBT sandals for men online with high-quality 8u[/url]
[url=http://www.domainnamestrategy.com/2009/11/13/glenn-beck-follow]There Offer the discount MBT sandals for women online with high-quality 6d[/url]
[url=http://www.honolulunews.net/index.php?sid/209249131/scat/a5a14b1515940e55]Here Offer the cheap MBT sandals shoes online with good quality 8s[/url]
[url=http://blog.penelopetrunk.com/2011/02/22/why-problem-employees-dont-get-fired/]There Offer the cheap MBT sandals for men online with high-quality 7b[/url]
[url=http://www.nationmaster.com/encyclopedia/Four-corner-method]There Offer the cheap MBT sandals for men online with high-quality 8s[/url]